THE AGE OF MAGICAL OVERTHINKING: NOTES ON MODERN IRRATIONALITY

Please note that this is a review for an ARC that I received from Atria Books via NetGalley. The books publishing date is 23 April 2024.

As an avid fan of Amanda Montell's previous works, including "Cultish" and "wordslut," I was over the moon to receive an advanced reader copy of her latest book, "The Age of Magical Overthinking." With her brilliant insights and engaging style, Montell has established herself as a shining star in the realm of cultural commentary.

However, my excitement quickly turned to disappointment as I delved into "The Age of Magical Overthinking." While I anticipated another binge-worthy read, I found myself struggling to connect with the writing. Unlike Montell's previous works, which were exciting and educational, this book left me feeling perplexed at times, unsure of its purpose and relevance to me as a reader.

Despite my eagerness to immerse myself in the book, I found it challenging to maintain interest, often reading in small portions at a time. Even then, I struggled to finish the book.

Moreover, the lack of storytelling and cohesion between chapters left me feeling adrift in a sea of potentially interesting ideas. Her neutral approach to tackling overthinking felt disconnected, lacking the depth and controversy I had anticipated. While Montell's wit still shines through in places, and the book's cover is undeniably gorgeous, I personally struggled to grasp the overarching theme or message.

Ultimately, "The Age of Magical Overthinking" fell short of my expectations. While it may still hold intrigue and provoke thought for some readers, I cannot wholeheartedly recommend it. Despite this disappointment, I remain a devoted fan of Amanda Montell and eagerly anticipate her future works.

Rating: 2 Stars.